The delicate balance between cost and quality in value-based healthcare
Financing the rising cost of healthcare is challenging, requiring difficult tradeoffs Policy Center, among others) addressing quality measurement have .. The cost of care and disparities in the U.S. may impact access to care. Many perceive that the US healthcare system delivers high-quality care. In fact, value is a composite of patient experience, quality and cost. Cost, access, and quality are the cornerstones of health care delivery, and these Distinguish between the roles of the federal and state governments in health Journal of the American Medical Association () that "the often advanced.
An estimated 20 million more people are insured because of the law, the increase in health care costs has declined sharply, and health care quality is improving following its enactment.
The Special Communication 1 by the president breaks some new ground; for example, by renewing a call for a public option on the exchanges created by the ACA.
Mostly, though, the report is a compendium of the numerous positive outcomes related to the law to date and how the worst concerns from creating massive job loss to substantial access problems have proven almost entirely untrue.
However, robust evidence demonstrating the actual health benefits of the coverage expansions is more tenuous than suggested, 23 and the article does not revisit medical malpractice reform focused on safe harbors for evidence-based care.
First, perhaps the most significant surprise since is the substantial deceleration in health care costs. The conventional wisdom at the time the ACA was enacted was that despite its ostensible dual mandate, the act largely addressed the coverage problem while doing almost nothing to address cost trends. That perspective was flawed and frustrating at the time, but even the most optimistic forecasts were conservative relative to what has since occurred. Imagine, for example, if anyone had been bold enough to predict in that Medicare spending per beneficiary would decline on an inflation-adjusted basis through Yet, as the president points out, that is precisely what has happened, and recent data suggest that the slowdown in Medicare expenditures has continued.
For employer-sponsored insurance, the evidence points strongly to the economic downturn as the primary impetus. There is more focus on the former because more people are affected by the upward pressure on deductibles, but given the extreme concentration of health spending, the latter matters just as much for the total dollars involved.
For Medicare, by contrast, the evidence shows little if any business cycle effect. Compensation models that put providers at risk for demonstration of value will certainly do this.
However, these models need to consider that the wear and tear of the human body that leads to disease is distinctly different and has more ramifications than the wear and tear that occurs in an automobile. This means retraining physicians and providers that value is indeed important to the consumer — something that will only happen when the compensation model changes.
Healthcare organizations that find the right balance among patient experience, quality and cost in delivering value-based care will be best positioned to surface as the winners in the market. But the true winners will be the patients who receive better care and, ultimately, live longer and healthier lives.
He is based in Charlotte, NC, and can be reached at yele. The accuracy, completeness and validity of any statements made within this article are not guaranteed.
We accept no liability for any errors, omissions or representations. The copyright of this content belongs to the author and any liability with regards to infringement of intellectual property rights remains with them. View our policies by clicking here. To receive the latest hospital and health system business and legal news and analysis from Becker's Hospital Review, sign-up for the free Becker's Hospital Review E-weekly by clicking here.
Distinguish between the roles of the federal and state governments in health policy with examples. Identify and describe the two types of Medicare approaches to improving hospital quality Examine the negative financial incentive of DRGs for hospital payment and critique the three ACA Medicare initiatives to improve both quality and efficiency. Describe two hospital initiatives designed to improve care transitions at discharge.
Cost of Health Care A goal of health reform is to increase access. A major goal of the ACA are to Increase insurance coverage through Medicaid expansion, state health exchanges, and the individual mandate.
The delicate balance between cost and quality in value-based healthcare
However, a possible unintended consequence of expanding coverage is that the shortage of primary care physicians will worsen as a result of an increase in the number of individuals trying to obtain care demand without increasing the already inadequate number of PCPs supply.
In addition, by providing more people with coverage, there will be an increase in care-seeking behavior and an increase of total health care costs. The hope is that increased coverage will improve the health of the population, but will this save money in the long run? Massachusetts began a process of health reform several years ahead of the ACA.
The first phase focused on increasing access health insurance coverage. More people are covered now, and it is costing more. The next phase in Massachusetts is to contain cost, but it is too early to know if this will succeed.
Americans' Views of Health Care Costs, Access, and Quality
Consumers might think of cost as the "price" we have to pay when we are presented with a physician's bill, or insurance premiums. The government looks at how much our country spends on health care expenditures for health insurance, organizations and institutions that deliver health services, pharmaceuticals, medical equipment, supplies, research costs, and the development of new technologies.
Another perspective comes from the providers themselves when considering salaries, capital and other operational costs. The ACA does contain substantial savings in Medicare, but limits on other spending are less robust.
The Association Between Health Care Quality and Cost A Systematic Review
The law initiates a broad array of experiments in medical care delivery and payment reform whose success is highly uncertain. Moreover, inefficiencies cause needless suffering. By one estimate, roughly 75, deaths might have been averted in if every state had delivered care at the quality level of the best performing state. Most medical debtors were well educated and middle class; three quarters had health insurance. According to the Researchers: Health economist Ewe E. Reinhardt writes in the Journal of the American Medical Association that "the often advanced idea that American patients should have "more skin in the game" through higher cost sharing, inducing them to shop around for cost-effective health care, so far has been about as sensible as blindfolding shoppers entering a department store in the hope that inside they can and will then shop smartly for the merchandise they seek.
Lack of price transparency: It is very difficult to find out how much a medical service will cost for a consumer. First, the institutions often do not make it easy to acquire information on the charge of services. Second, the charge is generally not the actual price to be paid payment. Third, the price to be paid varies across payors. Lack of availability of information on quality.
Linking Quality, Cost, and Outcomes
Generally speaking, consumers know less about medical care and treatment options than health providers. We call this information asymmetry. Even if consumers had access to standardized data on quality of care they would need the clinical knowledge to understand and interpret this information.
Would any other business survive if it behaved like a hospital?