Katherine R. Bellesheim Department of Psychological Sciences, University of multiple relationships; and balance ethical duties of beneficence and respect for . emotional, and psychological harm or trauma. 4. Clients Served by Others. Mental health counselors do not enter into counseling relationships with a person . Mental disorders: medical conditions or social labels? distinguish between physical and mental conditions? . has relied upon a linear relationship between theory and.
These policies must protect people with mental disorders from abuse, neglect, and discrimination, and afford them the care they need. Justice requires that people with mental illness receive the same societal and legal protection given to other people with physical health conditions. Ethical and human rights challenges in caring for people living with mental illness and their families exist.
Although the idea of health without mental health sounds absurd, mental health is perhaps the most neglected aspect of health in developed and developing nations. In defining health, the WHO clearly articulated the importance of mental health by including it with overall physical and social well-being. Neglect of mental health needs in health policies often translates to neglect in research, funding, services, and infrastructure e.
Mental health is vital to our understanding of health and economic development and must be prioritized in health planning, resource allocation and fully integrated with other primary care services. Footnotes Declaration of interest: The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.
Social distance towards people with mental illness amongst Nigerian university students. Social distance towards people with mental illness in southwestern Nigeria. Effects of a psychiatric education. Prevalence of childhood and early adolescence mental disorders among children attending primary health care centers in Mosul, Iraq: Prevalence of mental disorders and utilization of mental health services in two American Indian reservation populations: Mental health disparities in a national context.
American Journal of Psychiatry. Public health as social justice. Beauchamp DE, Steinbock B, editors. Oxford University Press; Workplace performance effects from chronic depression and its treatment. Journal of Health Economics. Psychiatric diagnoses and suicide: The high price of poverty. Poverty and debt are major risk factors for mental ill health in deprived communities and groups. Family involvement in routine health care: Journal of Family Practice. Lessons from rural providers.
Journal of Rural Health. Scale up services for mental disorders: A call for action. Beyond the health worker migration crisis. Social Science and Medicine. Social inequalities in mental health in Norway: International Journal of Equity in Health. Mental health and poverty in developing countries: Chronic physical illness, psychiatric disorder and disability in the workplace.
A new movement for global mental health and its possible impact in Nigeria.The relationship between mental and physical health
Nigerian Journal of Psychiatry. Health, human rights, and the new war on the poor.
University of California Press; Correlates of unmet need for mental health services by children and adolescents. Mental Health in the Workplace.
International Labour Office; Quality of life following spinal cord injury: Knowledge and attitudes of emergency care providers. Annals of Emergency Medicine. Understanding and Promoting Patient-Centered Care. Ethics, evidence and innovation. Global Forum Update on Research for Health. Fostering innovation for global health. Gureje O, Jenkins R. Mental health in development: Use of mental health services in a developing country. Results from the Nigerian survey of mental health and well-being.
Traditional healers in Southern Africa. Annals of Internal Medicine. Ethics and Culture in mental health care. A focus group study in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved. Social inequalities and perceived health. Mental health systems in countries: Results of a multisite survey.
Academic Psychiatry in press. Unmet need for mental health care among US children: A glossary for health inequalities. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. Prevalence and treatment of mental disorders, to New England Journal of Medicine. The impact of psychiatric disorders on work loss days. Results from the National Comorbidity Survey. Archieves of General Psychiatry.
Cost of mental and behavioural disorders in Kenya. Annals of General Hospital Psychiatry. The prevalence of mental disorders among children, adolescents and adults in the Western Cape, South Africa. South African Psychiatry Review. The treatment gap in mental health care. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. Important elements of outpatient care: Consultation liaison psychiatry at Kenyatta National Hospital, Nairobi. East Africa Medical Journal. Data to manage the mortality crisis: Recommendations to the substance abuse and mental health services administration.
Health and human rights. Achieving the Millennium Development Goals: Does mental health play a role?
Mental health and psychiatry in the Middle East: Eastern Mediterranean Health Journal. Poverty, social inequality and mental health. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment.
Murray C, Lopez A, editors. Global Burden of Disease and Injury Series. The global burden of disease: A comprehensive assessment of mortality and disability from diseases, injuries and risk factors in and projected to Murray M, Tantau C.
Journal of Quality Improvement. New Understanding New Hope. World Health Organization; Mwaniki D, Dulo C. Migration of Health Workers in Kenya: The Impact on Health Service Delivery.
The mental health situation in Kangemi informal settlement Nairobi, Kenya. The prevalence of mental disorders in adults in different level general medical facilities in Kenya: Annals of General Psychiatry.
Mental disorder ethics: theory and empirical investigation
Incentives for Health Worker Retention in Kenya: An Assessment of Current Practice. The challenges of human resources in mental health in Kenya. South African Psychiatric Review. Common mental disorders among those attending primary health clinics and traditional healers in urban Tanzania. The British Journal of Psychiatry. Unmet needs for specialty, dental, mental, and allied health care among children with special health care needs: Challenges of balanced care in Africa.
Mental health in Africa: The role of the WPA. Trauma, poverty and mental health among Somali and Rwandese refugees living in an African refugee settlement — An epidemiological study.
Traditional healers and mental illness in Uganda. Economic Cost of Chronic Disease in Canada — No health without mental health. Recruitment, consent, and debriefing. Stigma, hope, and challenge in psychiatry: Trainee perspectives from five countries on four continents. Complex medical conditions, such as Wesbecker's, had to be approached on their own terms.
In other words she argued that the relations between biochemistry and mental health and illness should be understood to be a question rather than the question. This perspective stresses that facts and values are convolved, in contrast to ethical and scientific approaches that seek to distinguish them.
The group recognised that interdisciplinary approaches might not be appropriate for the full range of research questions in ethics and mental health and that, in some areas, there would be advantage in examining issues via a range of separate empirical approaches and theoretical perspectives.
These studies might then form the basis for subsequent interdisciplinary collaborations. Risk assessment and management of mental disorders: Concerning values, key questions include what level of false positives in risk assessment is acceptable and who should make that decision? Hence, Szmukler argued, the policy that mental health practitioners should subject all patients to risk assessment is both flawed and profoundly illiberal, because it accepts that many will have to be detained in order to prevent one seriously violent act.
The question then arises: There was general agreement that the current practice of asking first, whether a person has a mental disorder, and second, whether they are a risk to others, is to address matters the wrong way round. Rather, the primary question is: Thereafter, consideration of whether to intervene, and in what way, might properly depend upon their mental health status.
Risk assessment is routinely used outside of health services—for example, in the airline industry.
Mental disorders, health inequalities and ethics: A global perspective
In these settings, it is assumed that mistakes will occur, and human frailty is acknowledged. Risk management systems are therefore designed to take account of the inevitability of human error. The group decided that the overriding principle at stake in this debate was justice; and, while there might be justification for discrimination against the mentally disordered, such discrimination needed to be justified.
Is mental incapacity researchable and, if so, how? General hospital and old age psychiatrists are frequently asked to assess whether patients with physical illness have mental capacity to make decisions regarding medical treatment.
The research also found that incapacity occurs often in general medical contexts and originates in physical rather than functional mental illness, and that clinicians miss many cases of incapacity. Most still spoke, however, of difficulties in decision making. This disparity reflected the distinction between cognitive and evaluative disabilities contributing to incapacity.
Tan identified some patients as having the ability to reflect on thought processes, but that those processes themselves seemed to be evidence of incapacity. This picture contrasted with the general hospital study by Hotopf, in which if patients lacked capacity they usually did so as a result of cognitive deficits, arising in turn from physical rather than functional mental ill health.
Tan hopes her research will contribute to a more subtle and interactive understanding of capacity. Others emphasised the importance of assessing volitional impairment of patients exhibiting—for example, anorexia nervosa, substance abuse, addiction to substances, and deliberate self harm. Overall, this body of research aims to clarify the concept of incompetent refusal of treatment, to help resolution of clinical ethical dilemmas involving patients who frequently resist or refuse treatment, and to provide policy solutions for managing treatment refusal, given the current wide range of professionals' responses to such patients.
How can empirical research reflect and inform theoretical ethics? A second main aim of the meeting was to focus on methodological issues as such, and in particular on the interrelations of empiricism and theory.
The classical model of biomedical ethics has relied upon a linear relationship between theory and data, within which a clinical dilemma gives rise to a real issue of concern for medical ethics, which then results in an application.
Hope argued, however, that a more useful representation of empirical ethics would rely on a cyclical model in which ethical analysis, empirical issues, new data, and empirical studies inform each other in a continuum. Empirical ethics must therefore be normative in some way. It must include systematic collection of empirical data, and the ethical analysis must affect the empirical design, and vice versa. In an accompanying presentation, Alastair Campbell Professor of Ethics in Medicine, University of Bristol refuted the notion that philosophy is irrelevant to mental health policy and practice.
Rather, it's application of rigorous moral reasoning, going beyond simply stated principles, and it's wealth of theory about morality can both enrich and add critical value to the domain.
It was suggested that smaller and developing frontier areas should be focused upon, such as confidentiality, screening, behavioural genetics, enhancement, and direct alteration of brain function. However, others expressed concern that the familiar problems should not, or even could not, be neglected, since they are enduring precisely because they are inevitable, and are often reflected in smaller and more specifically defined questions. Policy related research The meeting highlighted that mental health policy is a rich source for ethics research, exemplified by the frequent tension within policy between pursuit of paternalism and autonomy.
A policy issue as such, does not necessarily infer an ethics research question, however; and ethics research that is policy led may move away from the conceptual. Also, ideally, a research portfolio in this area would contain projects with immediate policy relevance and projects examining underlying key issues, including investigation pursued over time and in different policy contexts. Investigation of communication and language is therefore central to this field of research. Much policy is played out in law, and several ethicolegal topics for future research emerged: Defining mental disorders Potential future areas and questions for exploration in this area were identified: Treatment of mental disorders Research proposals here included: Risk assessment Proposed research topics here included: Capacity Much research into mental disorder ethics currently focuses on the definition and operation of capacity.
Yet the results of this research seem to be poorly translated into policy and practice, and many clinicians are still unsure how to use the concept in various circumstances. Even in the USA, where mental health statutes are often based on capacity assessment, such statutes arguably have had little impact, since patients with mental disorders still experience greater violation of their human rights than patients with physical disorders.
Valuable research might therefore focus on how often, and by what means, people with mental disorders are compelled into treatment compared with those with physical disorders.
Methods The meeting emphasised that biomedical ethics research is not naturally limited to any one discipline and is likely to benefit from an interdisciplinary approach within an increasingly better understood relationship between theoretical and empirical methods.
It became clear that mutual incomprehensions were common between disciplines and that for interdisciplinarity truly to work, an understanding of each discipline by the other must precede collaborative working—that is, interdisciplinarity is not additive but interactive.
Much discussion surrounded ethical analysis, its boundaries, and its relationship with empirical inquiry. Rather than being seen as at odds with Hope's model, however, such diversity can be incorporated into the cycle of empirical ethics research, and if empirical data are inconsistent with ethical analysis this can, in turn, stimulate further productive research.
This reflected a natural tendency toward conflict between theoreticians and empiricists. Conclusion What can be learned from this meeting and where might, or should, it take us? As well as focusing on ethical aspects of mental health policy and law, the meeting emphasised the need to address fundamental questions concerning the definition of mental disorder and treatment, as well as the assessment of incapacity and risk arising from mental disorder.
The role of values was seen as central not only to balancing the rights of the individual against those of society but also to defining disorders and treatment as such. Here Fulford's construction provides a helpful model for addressing professional roles in relation to conditions that can be constructed either medically or sociocriminologically.
Fraser's inclusive notion of treatment clearly justifies therapeutic eclecticism—that is, drawing on the total range of treatments available. And Matthews's definition of mental disorder, seen as failure of function of the whole person, might be used similarly to support relatively unrestricted use of mental health care, and legislation directed toward patient and public welfare. These latter approaches counter the Szaszian restrictive definitional approach, which is designed heavily to limit the social role of mental health care.
Differentiated legal treatment of physical and mental disorders also became a particular focus of the meeting: Finally, based on the deliberations of this meeting, biomedical ethics is clearly not a discipline but a field of inquiry. Acknowledgements The meeting referred to in this paper was sponsored by the Wellcome Trust.
The authors would like to thank all the participants at the meeting, in particular the speakers for their contributions and agreeing to make their presentations available for this report. BS is an employee of the Wellcome Trust. The myth of mental illness: Harper and Row, 2. Law, liberty and psychiatry.
Fulford K W M. Moral theory and medical practice. Cambridge University Press, 4. Analytic philosophy, brain science and the concept of disorder.
Oxford University Press, 5. Hart Publications, 6. Department of Health National service framework for mental health: Mental Health Alliance Submission to the joint parliamentary scrutiny committee for the draft mental health bill.
Mental Health Act Commission Submission to the joint parliamentary scrutiny committee for the draft mental health bill. The Stationery Office,Ev 39, 9. Evidence to the joint parliamentary scrutiny committee for the draft mental health bill. Bartlett A, Phillips L. Decision making and mental health law. Hart Publications, Competence to refuse treatment in anorexia nervosa.